I can’t believe this is the 13th peanut butter review. Considering each review consists of at least 3 varieties, that’s a lot of peanut butter! But I guess it’s only fitting for the Peanut Butter Boy. This time around, I have a special treat for you – this review consists of a unique peanut butter brand that is difficult to find (for now!).


My Better Butter Maple Pumpkin

= 80%
My Better Butter is a peanut-based spread that uses healthy additions (such as fresh pumpkin or bananas) to inject flavor while decreasing the calories by about 50%. Because of this, all of these flavors need to be refrigerated. This one in particular reminds me of Thanksgiving, which despite being a few months past, doesn’t make it any less enticing. The texture is close to pumpkin puree but a bit thicker, perhaps closer to frosting – and it doesn’t taste all that different from frosting either! The ingredients are peanuts, pumpkin, maple syrup, cinnamon, ginger, all spice, nutmeg, and sea salt. It’s sweet without being overly so, and despite being cold when eaten out of the fridge, it still makes you feel warm and cozy inside. As such, this flavor is great on toast or a bagel. And I imagine this would make one killer pumpkin pie!

My Better Butter Honey Nut Banana

= 75%
The name sounds delicious. The aroma is enticing. The flavor doesn’t disappoint. While I was sampling this flavor, I thought it would make the perfect Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Bread, but the flavor is already so much like banana bread that I feared the flavor would be wasted in the bread. A smooth consistency makes it go down easily and the texture is similar to the green wasabi paste you get in Japanese restaurants. Great to eat by itself but it’s the perfect flavor to use for Peanut Butter Cereal.

My Better Butter Nutty Chocolate Chip

= 85%
The texture of this one is similar to Nutella but a bit thicker. It’s not very spreadable (at least when it’s cold), but the flavor more than makes up for it. It’s a rich, thick chocolate peanut butter that kicks it up a notch by adding chocolate chips. The other two flavors were exactly as their names suggest, but I feel this one deserves more credit. Without those chocolate chips it would be just another chocolate peanut butter, but with them it’s a different story. I think this flavor should be called “Double Chocolate Chip” because it kinda tastes like you’re eating double chocolate chip cookie dough. Great for a Peanut Butter Hot Dog if you can get it to spread.

Filed in Peanut Butter, Reviews

116 Responses / Leave a comment »

  1. Evan Thomas says:

    I would trust your taste if I won and go with Nutty Chocolate Chip.

  2. Lauren says:

    I would absolutely choose the Maple Pumpkin flavor! Sounds absolutely delicious :).

  3. Lauren says:

    I tweeted the giveaway :).

  4. Lauren says:

    I posted the giveaway on my Facebook page!

  5. kim says:

    Maple anything is amazing! :)

  6. kim says:

    I tweeted! kd316

  7. I want to try the pumpkin or chocolate chip!

  8. Brad says:

    I think Honey Nut Banana would be delicious!

  9. The nutty chocolate chip sounds really good!

  10. DEFINITELY Nutty Chocolate Chip! PB & Chocolate is my favorite combination.

  11. Those flavors all sound right up my alley, but I’m gonna go with the Honey Nut Banana! PB and banana is my go-to combo most days.

  12. Lisa says:

    Oh *drool*! I’m totally intrigued by the nutty chocolate chip one!

  13. Whitney N says:

    Nutty chocolate chip! They all sound awesome, though.

  14. Maple Pumpkin sounds very unique, and I find myself craving it, just by the title alone!

  15. Nive says:

    I would choose ‘Maple Pumpkin’ flavor…thanks for this giveaway…

  16. melissa says:

    Definitely the Nutty Chocolate Chip — I can’t get enough peanut butter with chocolate!

  17. melissa says:

    I tweeted (@meliwai)!

  18. melissa says:

    Also posted on FB!

  19. Raychel says:

    I would LOVE to try the banana honey peanut butter! Three of my favorite ingredients in one package! What could be better?

  20. Marissa Musso says:

    I tweeted the giveaway and posted it as my status on facebook :)

  21. MLT says:

    You can never go wrong with PB & chocolate. Nutty Chocolate Chip gets my vote!

  22. Marissa Musso says:

    and I love honey with peanut butter, especially with banana!! so My Better Butter Honey Nut Banana would definitely be my favorite!!

  23. Joanne says:

    Honey Nut Butter is my choice all the way! Delicious!

  24. Joanne says:

    I tweeted this SUPER- DUPER, FANTASTIC giveaway (but didn’t want too) ;) … more for me :)

  25. Joanne says:

    I also did the dirty deed on Facebook. Pick ME! I love my PB!

  26. Martha says:

    I think I’d have to go for the Honey Nut Banana flavor…PB and banana is always a classic! Thanks for the chance to win. :)

  27. Juli says:

    Anytime you can mix PB and chocolate you have my full attention.

  28. Shannon says:

    nutty choc chip, for sure :) although i’m intrigued by the maple pumpkin too!

  29. Kristen says:

    I would LOVE to try My Better Butter Maple Pumpkin. ANything with pumpkin is amazing!

  30. Nicole says:

    The Nutty chocolate chip has me interested! Verrrrrrrry interested!

  31. Heidi says:

    You can’t go wrong with chocolate and peanut butter! I think Nutty Chocolate Chip has potential for some yummy desserts!

  32. Lori says:

    I was leaning towards the pumpkin until I saw you rated the chocolate chip higher. You are the Peanut Butter Boy so I would go with your top pick!

  33. Heidi says:

    I tweeted the contest! (@runner725)

  34. Jordan says:

    I would love to try the chocolate chip flavor, chocolate and peanut butter are awesome!

  35. Jordan says:

    Tweeted this giveaway at thisbeangreen!

  36. Sagan says:

    You sold me at “double chocolate chip cookie dough”. Um, yes please! I’m all over the Nutty Chocolate Chip.

    Well, thanks a lot, Nick. Now I’m thinking about cookies. Specifically ones with chocolate and PB in them. OH MY GOODNESS now I really want to get the Nutty Chocolate Chip nut butter and use it to make PB chocolate chip cookies. Mmmm!

  37. Vanessa says:

    Oh my goodness! I’d love to have the nutty chocolate chip! I’ll go nuts if I win!!

  38. Vanessa says:

    Tweeted for you!!

  39. Vanessa says:

    My facebook profile says it all! However, I’d like to keep it a secret to up my chances. I REALLY NEED THIS PEANUT BUTTER!!!

  40. Jonna says:

    I would love to try the maple pumpkin butter! I would actually like to try any of them, they all sound great and I love peanut butter/nut butters! Thanks!

  41. Casey G. says:

    I tweeted!


  42. A.B. says:

    Ohhh! I think the Nutty Chocolate Chip flavor is the peanut butter of my dreams! I. Must. Try. It. :D

  43. Lisa says:

    I love pumpkin pie, so I would choose the maple pumpkin flavor for sure!

  44. Maddie says:

    Definitely maple pumpkin – I’m sure it would taste AMAZING on oatmeal!!

  45. karen says:

    honey nut banana sounds good to me.

  46. Erica says:

    I would love to try the Maple Pumpkin flavor!

  47. Dorinda Norton says:

    Any peanutbutter flavor I won would be grateful. I love the Peanut Boys recipe. I try to buy as my budget allows. I am 63 years old and still loving peanut butter sandwiches everyday

  48. Juliette says:

    The Maple Pumpkin sounds fantastic!

  49. jacquie says:

    the maple pumpkin as i love pumpkin.

  50. Mallory says:

    I absolutely adore maple, so I would LOVE to try the Maple Pumpkin!

  51. Mallory says:

    I tweeted about the giveaway!


  52. Matthew says:

    They all sound so damned amazing…..i’d have to go with Honey Nut Banana

  53. briana says:

    Definately the pumpkin sounds awesome!

  54. Amy Weber says:

    I’d love to try them all, but I’d have to say the Maple Pumpkin Butter sounds unique and delicious!

  55. Susan says:

    I am so intrigued by the Honey Nut Banana flavor- sounds amazing!

  56. Cole says:

    Hope I get this! Love the blog, peanut butter is my addiction!

  57. Lauren says:

    I’m a peanut butter addict. I would absolutely love to win peanut butter! That Maple Pumpkin flavor looks absolutely AWESOME!

  58. Anisha says:

    i can’t decide between maple pumpkin or nutty chocolate chip!! chocolate may just win out though..

  59. Cole says:

    oh and the maple pumpkin sounds the best!

  60. christine says:

    The peanut butter chocolate chip sounds delicious!!

  61. Tracy says:

    They all 3 sound great, but I think Nutty Chocolate Chip is the one I’d most like to try. Thanks for the great website!

  62. tasha says:

    I would have to claim the Honey Nut Banana as my first flavor choice to try.

  63. Nichole says:

    Would love to sample them all, but the pumpkin maple is right up my alley.

  64. Nichole says:


  65. Nichole says:

    posted on fb

  66. Carly says:

    Maple Pumpkin! YUM!

  67. Holly says:

    If I don’t win this giveaway… I’m absolutely trying to make all 3 flavors on my own! But… I’d really like to win :)

  68. Hanna says:

    I would definitely choose the Nutty Chocolate Chip!

  69. Rachel says:

    despite my chocolate blog, i have to go with the honey nut banana. bananas and peanut butter truly are one of the best flavor combinations; add honey and a dash of cinnamon and you’re golden!

  70. this is a HARD ONE!
    maple pumpkin i think :)

    great give away!

  71. susitravl says:

    Nutty Chocolate Chip!! Sounds so good.

  72. Jules says:

    But of course… my Better Butter Nutty Chocolate Chip!!

  73. Laura says:

    Honey nut banana… it was good enough for Elvis, nuff said.

  74. Laura says:

    Well, considering the fact that I LOVE bananas & I also LOVE pumpkin with all my heart, I think I’d have to choose both the Honey Nut Banana AND the Maple Pumpkin :)

  75. Katie says:

    Maple Pumpkin sounds amazing!!!!

  76. Meagan says:

    Honey Nut Banana!

  77. Meagan says:

    Tweeted! @vivalameaganx3

  78. Anne says:

    I would love to win a jar of My Better Butter – Nutty Chocolate Chip PB! Sounds healthy AND delicious!

  79. Anne says:

    tweeted (@pbandanne)

  80. Anne says:


  81. liketocook says:

    The Maple Pumpkin description makes my mouth water! I can imagine a whole host of possibilities for enjoying it. The other flavors also sound wonderful but the Maple Pumpkin gets my vote.

  82. gigi says:

    deffinitly the Nutty Chocolate Chip, I love chocolate chips in my pb!
    I tried one of your pb 101 tricks today with a jar of Naturally More PB, I love the texture of this brand. I put half of it in an empty jar and stirred each separately, usually this is the most difficult (and tiresome) brand to stir, but this technique worked like a charm!

  83. jperonto says:

    THESE SOUND AMAZING! I would definitely try Nutty Chocolate Chip first, but they all seem like great flavors!. Thanks for a great giveaway!

  84. Cheryl Casperson says:

    Nutty Chocolate Chip for sure

  85. Cheryl Casperson says:


  86. Kim Oakes says:

    My Better Butter Maple Pumpkin sounds heavenly.

  87. ikkinlala says:

    May Canadians enter? I’d love to try Nutty Chocolate Chip.

  88. Kristen D says:

    I would try the variety pack, it sounds like the best!

  89. Crystalis! says:

    Honey Nut Banana for me, please!

  90. Vivienne says:

    Oooh my goodness…..I would spread the Honey Nut Butter on a muffin, the Maple Pumpkin in oatmeal and the Nutty Chocolate Chip for a yummy cookie! Thanks so much for posting the giveaway!

  91. Melissa says:

    If I could only try one of these better butters it would hands down be the Honey Nut Banana!!! Aahhhh sounds SO delicious. I’ve only had creamy and crunchy peanut butter, so this would be a GREAT change. mmmmm

  92. funmi alabi says:

    i tweeted! n i would like to win the variety pack!!! if i can only win one than the pumpkin flavor!!!

  93. Caroline says:

    I would choose maple pumpkin!

  94. Dana says:

    mmmmm maple pumpkin sounds fab!!!

  95. Campbell Morrissy says:

    Maple Pumpkin! Its like making a pumpkin butter, peanut butter sandwich without any work.

  96. Jessica Leigh says:

    Hmm Hmm Hmm Maple Pumpkin sounds absolutely delightful!

  97. Rachel Eddington says:

    No Fair! I only have a facebook account to post to. X( Whatevs, I posted it on facebook, and although it’s a hard choice I’d go with My Better Butter Nutty Chocolate Chip.

  98. Hannah Eddington says:

    ooooo! i want to try the maple pumpkin butter.
    I posted the url on my facebook page!

  99. Andrea H says:

    It’s all about the Nutty Chocolate Chip… or at least it looks like it’s all about that- I’ve never tried it but would love to!

    skidownthehill at yahoo dot com

  100. MegSmith says:

    I would so go with the Nutty Chocolate Chip. There is no combination better than chocolate and PB. LOVE IT!

  101. LE says:

    Nutty Chocolate Chi … erm or Maple Pumpkin, I can’t decide!

  102. LE says:

    I tweeted.

  103. LE says:

    I update my status on Facebook.

  104. kathy says:

    nothing goes better with pb than chocolate!

  105. Angela says:

    The honey banana sounds amazing!

  106. Brian says:

    The combination of banana and peanut butter is already so classic, completing the trifecta with honey makes the Honey Nut Banana sound perfect!

  107. Octavio Perez says:

    Updated my facebook status!

  108. Jessica says:

    MMMMM Maple Pumpkin now please!

  109. Joni says:

    maple =)

  110. Katie says:

    Maple Pumpkin!!

  111. Isabel Menendez says:

    My Better Butter Nutty Chocolate Chip
    this would be my daily viatmin cH fix!!!!

  112. Pam Ocampo says:

    I’m a sucker for honey nut banana

  113. Holly Ellerton says:

    Yummmmmy….. Nutty chocolate Chip! Chocolate and PB are my favorites! Definitely my first choice, but the other flavors sound delicious as well.

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to PBB recipes by email?


Peanut Butter Grilled CheeseChocolate Peanut Butter Oatmeal ShakePumpkin Pie OatmealPeanut Butter and Tomato on ToastCinnamon Bourbon TrufflesPeanut Butter & Banana Omelet
Copyright © 2006- Peanut Butter Boy, LLC ContactAdvertiseAbout