Being the Peanut Butter Boy is a tough job, there seems to be an endless supply of peanut butter brands and varieties. I’m not complaining though, and if you run your own nut butter company I’ll gladly review your nut butters! This round of reviews covers some fairly common brands and varieties. My current favorite peanut butter is also reviewed, I think I’ve waited so long to review it because I’ve been busy inhaling jar after jar. There is 1 review of a brand that I have never seen before but luckily the Peanut Butter of the Month Club brought it to my doorstep. I can proudly say I have 5 more peanut butters under my belt. Read on for the reviews or to see all of my peanut butter reviews, click here.


365 Creamy Peanut Butter

= 100%
My new favorite peanut butter. This creamy peanut butter has a fairly coarse grind which makes for a wonderful grainy, almost gritty texture. It is also perfectly salted despite a lower sodium content than most other salted peanut butters. The peanut flavor is outstanding. I use this peanut butter for everything, but my preferred method of consumption is with a fork. It is truly a meal in a jar. I recommend it for everything including making flavored peanut butter like spicy or cinnamon raisin. As a bonus, this is also the cheapest peanut butter on the market ($1.79, 18oz) and can be found easily, since it is the store brand of Whole Foods.

365 Crunchy Peanut Butter

= 100%
My other new favorite peanut butter. This crunchy peanut butter has the same gritty coarse grind with the additional of some fantastic chunks in between. Again, it’s perfectly salted despite a lower sodium content. I tend to use this variety for sandwiches, but I bet this would be great for making cinnamon raisin peanut butter for some additional chunks. Same price as the creamy variety ($1.79, 18oz), and you can’t beat it! The only downsides to this variety is that there was one jar I was disappointed with. It had minimal flavor and was too thick. I was actually debating whether or not I truly ever liked the brand, but it was just a fluke. Since it’s natural, every batch is slightly different, perhaps it was less roasted or salted. And another time I got a small piece of bark or wood (I hope), since it was too tough to be a peanut shell. But neither of these have deterred me from purchasing this peanut butter whenever possible!

365 Organic Unsalted Creamy Peanut Butter

= 70%
This organic variety costs quite a bit more, almost double. Using what I learned in “Economics for Engineers”, one would assume twice the quality or at least some flakes of gold in it. Overall, disappointing. The peanut flavor is decent but nothing to rave about. It was a little better with salt but still lacked in flavor. The texture is nice and silky, but a bit on the sticky side. I did find one use for it – it works well in banana pudding, since it is unsalted and it doesn’t steal the show, so to speak. However, there is no comparison to the non-organic version above. On the plus side, it tastes better than glue.

Arrowhead Mills Crunchy Peanut Butter

= 80%
I’ve often seen this brand but never purchased it before, probably because it’s fairly expensive, coming in at $6.99 for a 28oz jar. My mother purchased 2 large jars of it for me, mistaking it for the 365 crunchy peanut butter. Regardless, this peanut butter has nice large chunks that have a very good crunch. It is very creamy between the chunks and has an overall stickiness as a result. It comes unsalted, so I recommend adding some kosher salt. Overall, it’s very similar to Krema Crunchy. Good, but for the price I’d rather get double the amount of the 365 brand.

Bazzini Old Fashioned Peanut Butter

= 85%
This is one brand that I have never seen nor heard of and I have the Peanut Butter of the Month Club to thank for this one. It comes in a cheap plastic container (on the right) that was dented from being vacuum packed, and the label was printed poorly and affixed crooked – I didn’t have high hopes for this brand. Despite it’s lackluster appearance, this peanut butter delivered on flavor but even more on texture. This peanut butter has a nice rich peanut flavor and a very smooth grind. The texture was unlike anything I’ve had before. It is almost fluffy, like buttercream frosting. It is smooth and airy, and goes down with ease. I generally dislike unsalted peanut butter but this one is fantastic. Even so, I mixed in some kosher salt to suit my tastes. This peanut butter is apparently made in the neighboring city of Manhattan, at a small shop in the Tribeca area. I’m hoping to go pick up some more!

Smuckers Natural Creamy Peanut Butter

= 70%
This is a good standard peanut butter that you can find in almost any store. It is similar in texture to 365 but not quite as coarse and grainy. It is a little too salty but good when used to make spicy peanut butter. I’ve had this brand several times and the flavor and color range from a medium to dark brown, representing the level of roasting. The peanut flavor is decent but gets overwhelmed by salt. I forget the cost, but it’s certainly a better option than Skippy.

Filed in Peanut Butter, Reviews

32 Responses / Leave a comment »

  1. dawn says:

    365 organic chunky is my go-to. the best I’ve ever tasted in pb and I’ve tasted a lot.

  2. Evan Thomas says:

    Great reviews! I love the 365 creamy for just about any time I have to bake with peanut butter. The Bazinni sounds wicked good, too. I’ll have to see if I can track that down online

  3. Gina says:

    I just discovered Smucker’s natural extra crunchy peanut butter and it’s my new favorite!
    I used to really enjoy the Smart Balance peanut butter, until I started noticing it smelled like fish! I always call the company and complain but things have not changed :( I miss it!

    • Nick says:

      Like fish? That’s horrible. Funny though, because I’m out of town this week and decided to try a new brand while I’m traveling. I almost got the Smart Balance one but opted for Jif Natural instead. Does it smell that way when you first open it or later on? Maybe the added oils (flax and others) are going bad quickly.

      I love salt and I especially love my peanut butter salted but I find the Smucker’s brand to be too salty. It has a good flavor but way too much salt, or maybe it was just the batch I had.

  4. VeggieGirl says:

    Yay!! I always look forward to your reviews :)

  5. Julia says:

    I like to take peanut butter and spread it thinly across piece of toast and then run it under the broiler till the peanut butter bubbles. I can’t wait till it cools down enough to eat so I usually end up burning the roof of my mouth but it is so good!

  6. Jessica says:

    Yum! Great reviews! I love it here!

  7. Yum, Smuckers reminds me of my childhood – it’s all my mom would let us buy! I do find the amount of stirring required a little annoying…

    • Nick says:

      I’ve got some good tips for that, read the peanut butter boy method for storing peanut butter. Essentially it boils down to doing one good stir to begin with and splitting it into separate jars, keeping one out and one in the fridge. Less stirring the entire jar and spilling over the edge.

  8. Michal says:

    Your reviews are really helpful! And a pb of the month club sounds like so much fun :)

  9. Gina says:

    Yes, the peanut butter tasted like fish right away, and smelled like it. I found that some of the jars were worse than others. I called the company and they said that the flax sometimes has that type of smell. I think they are all rancid! It’s just not a normal smell, at all, and I was so turned off. When the Smart Balance does not taste like fish, it’s some of the best peanut butter I have EVER had! IF not the best.

    • Anne says:

      re: the fish smell – if there are flax oils added, it is very likely that it was going rancid, since once it is ground/pressed/processed, flax goes bad really quickly if not stored in the freezer

      as always, love your peanut butter reviews! I just wish 1/2 of these brands were available in Canada!

      • Nick says:

        Haha, thanks Anne. I just found that you can buy Arrowhead Mills online at But some of the better brands I’ve reviewed prior are available to ship (Naturally Nutty, Eastwind) from the company themselves but then you’d need to pay for shipping.

        Best bet, take a border trip and stock up. Rent a truck if you have to!

  10. Nora says:

    Just popping by to say great reviews! Love to read your site. :)THe Smucker’s Natural is the same company that makes Laura Scudder’s. I have to say they are pretty similar in taste–but I agree that it’s a bit too salty. I really want to become part of the PB of the month club! How fun!

  11. Audra says:

    Mmm…I like the Smuckers best of what I can find locally in the chain grocery stores. My toddler is put off by the texture I think…gonna have to get some “buttah” that’s a bit smoother for her.

  12. scratch and dent says:

    I would just say one thing to you and that is, “FANTASTIC”!! Keep it up and wish to get more details from your blog.

  13. Miles says:

    My favorite peanut butter is Trader Joe’s crunchy unsalted.

  14. Paul Schubert says:

    I suppose that I am not much of a purest because I usually add a touch of honey to my natural peanut butter to reduce the “sticky” and oil separation for the benefit of my “streight from the jar” addiction. Be that as it may, I wuld like to get your reading on the Trader Joes PB for, in contrast to most or the naturals I have found, the peanuts are both unblanched and dry roasted.

    • Nick says:

      Adding honey reduces the stickiness? When I add honey to a natural peanut butter, it tends to tighten up the peanut butter and I always considered it more “sticky” but it does help with the oil separation. It certainly makes it delicious though =)

      I love Trader Joe’s peanut butter, specifically the natural creamy and the crunchy valencia w/ flaxseed. I reviewed the natural creamy: here and the valencia w/ flaxseed: here. Their natural creamy is the thinnest, creamiest peanut butter I’ve ever found. It’s great for making flavored peanut butters, specifically Cinnamon Raisin and Hot & Spicy, my two favorites.

Links To This Post

  1. Product Love – 365 Everyday Value Peanut Butter « Alicia Parr’s Adventures

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to PBB recipes by email?


Cheesy Bacon PB OatmealDone in 60 Seconds: Peanut Butter Hot DogHot and Spicy Peanut ButterPeanut Butter Banana PuddingMexican Tortilla PiePeanut Butter Reviews - Part 01
Copyright © 2006- Peanut Butter Boy, LLC ContactAdvertiseAbout